In star‑wrought crystal burned a living fire,
A light unbroken since the world was young.
No forge but spirit shaped that secret pyre,
No hand but one from whom all songs are sprung.
They shone like prayers sealed in a holy stone,
Too pure for oath or grief to hold or bind.
Yet hearts were stirred, and kingdoms overthrown,
For beauty fierce enough to unmake mind.
Still in the dark, their hidden radiance gleams—
One in the sea, one in the deathless sky,
One in the earth where sorrow folds its dreams,
Each guarded now by silence none defy.
So let their light remain beyond all will—
A shrine of fire the world remembers still.
My 3DXChat life 
The sonnet form feels exactly right for a poem about the Silmarils, contained and luminous like the gems themselves. The line “For beauty fierce enough to unmake mind” captures Tolkien’s central tragedy so precisely, the idea that the purest things can also be the most destructive forces. I love how you resolve the final couplet with the image of them as a shrine that exists beyond reach or will. The meter holds beautifully throughout and the tone is reverent without being stiff. This is the kind of fan poetry that would genuinely please the Tolkien society crowd.
LikeLiked by 1 person